Ad Catalyst

Ad Catalyst

💔 How to tell if someone doesn’t like you

Pettiness is forever ❤️‍🔥

Oct 14, 2025
∙ Paid

🔥What’s Hot in Advertising Right Now

Stay up-to-date with the latest advertising trends and news.

5 interesting marketing stats to start your week

AI creator content is exploding, influencer ROI is beating TV, and new data shows where smart marketers are quietly winning.

Amazon is primed to take over the ad industry
Amazon isn’t just creeping into ad tech—it’s quietly assembling the infrastructure, data, and partnerships to become the ad powerhouse the industry never saw coming.

American Eagle’s CMO on Why Doing ‘Nothing’ Was the Boldest Move
American Eagle’s CMO reveals staying silent amid online backlash became the boldest play in their playbook.

CMOs share what brands get wrong when marketing to Gen Z
Don’t mistake Gen Z’s skepticism for apathy—they’ll rally behind brands that talk with them, not at them.


Remember crossing out faces in your yearbook? BIC does:

A few months ago, I caught myself doom scrolling on Instagram.

It started with “just one more reel” and ended with “oh look, it’s 2:00am 😅.”

That was the moment I realized I needed to clean house.

I went through my following list, channeled my inner Marie Kondo, and cut out any accounts that “didn’t spark joy.”

These days, unfriending someone on social media is as easy as the click of a button.

But back in the day – when people only had photo prints – unfriending looked a bit different (yes, Gen Zers, we’re taking a trip back in time ⌛).

Before social media, if you didn’t like someone, you had to cross their face out in pen, cut them out of photos, or whatever floated your boat.

Maybe you even wrote about them in a Burn Book (looking at you, Regina 💅).

a woman walking down a hallway with yellow lockers and a sign on the wall that says ' e '

That’s where BIC’s nostalgic ad comes in.

Targeting older Millennials, Gen Xers, and Boomers – the generations that still reach for pens – BIC taps into a memory only these generations can relate to.

They feature an 80s yearbook with faces aggressively crossed out in pen, paired with the tagline: Unfriending long before social media.

This ad works because it taps into nostalgic irony by connecting old-school pettiness with modern digital culture.

It reframes a contemporary behavior through a vintage lens, reminding us that human drama and self-expression existed long before the Internet.

(And let’s face it… one computer click just doesn’t give the same satisfaction as aggressively crossing someone out in permanent ink 🖊️).

BIC transforms an ordinary pen from a simple writing tool into a powerful symbol of emotional release and identity.

Turns out, the pen is mightier than the block button.


BIC took a stroll down memory lane in their print ad.

This next one breaks free from past generations.

Upgrade to premium to read it:

🧼 Smelling like your mom isn’t doing you any favors

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Ad Catalyst.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Ad Catalyst · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture